Facing Reality in Retail: Embracing a Proactive Mindset for Success

In our fast-paced, always-evolving retail landscape, knowing where you stand in most performance indicators is a critical element for every retail leader. Whether you are running a department, store, district, region, or the chain, having accurate information about the state of the business is paramount.

With that comes the need for separating reality from the outcomes you hope you will see. The ability to confront brutal truths, embrace challenges, and make better, more informed decisions is what will set the best part from others. Observing with an open mind, using data driven analysis, and creating an honest environment are some ways you can ensure you are addressing the right issues, in the right ways. Let’s explore what you can do as a leader to ensure you are facing your realities head on.

In his book "Good to Great," Jim Collins emphasizes the concept of "facing the brutal truth" as a key characteristic of successful companies. Collins argues that great companies are not afraid to confront the harsh realities of their situation, regardless of how unpleasant or challenging they may be.

According to Collins, facing the brutal truth involves having a realistic understanding of the company's current state, market conditions, and competitive landscape. It requires leaders to acknowledge and accept the uncomfortable realities that may exist within their organization, such as poor performance, outdated strategies, or a need for significant change.

When you start with an honest and diligent effort to determine the truth of your situation, the right decisions often become self-evident. — Jim Collins

Leaders must be honest with themselves. If you sugar coat everything, nothing changes. If you justify constantly, you’re falling behind. You must look at your situation and surroundings and be brutally honest with yourself and your team.

Reward and celebrate open and honest communication

You must establish a culture and environment that allows the team, at any level, to surface and speak the truth about the situations they face. It can be the part-time hourly associate that experiences problems every time they use the store’s technology. That will always impact their level of service and engagement. Do they have an open channel to be heard? Will they be believed? This opening to reality must be safe and even encouraged. Recognizing and rewarding the sharing of feedback, even if the difficulty cannot be immediately resolved, is critical to ensuring you will always have a view into the team’s reality.

Data driven approach

We all look at metrics, reports, and survey data. How often do we immediately begin to rationalize the information? That was “just one week.” “That is not really how my team is engaging with customers.” “I had some key people off during that time.” Some of these may sound familiar. There are also tendencies to look through several reports to find the ones that indicate bright spots. The fact is that data rarely lies. Sure, some of it may be a limited set of points, but they are likely indicating something. Even one customer survey, out of hundreds of shoppers, may point to a problem that you can get ahead of before it becomes hundreds of other customers. A department report with down trending numbers may be an indication that something is wrong, and it could lead to other areas following similar trends. Wouldn’t you want to know that as soon as possible, versus waiting until all the numbers get softer? Use the information and data you have and trust it first, then dig into what the real meaning might be.

Assess everything

Using data can point you in the right direction for what needs more immediate information. Conducting assessments through observation or conversations can fill in the details you cannot see in aa report. If you think you might have a customer service issue from the report, then go stand on your sales floor and watch for a few hours. You can find out a lot through any observation. Additionally, talk to the team, ask questions, be curious. This, as much as observations, can provide insights that no report will ever uncover. These ‘front line’, first hand data points can fill in the blanks you need to build a productive and effective action plan to address your situation.

"The key to becoming a more proactive leader is to engage in keen observation. The more you observe, the more you can respond effectively." — Linda Fisher Thornton

Learn from failures

Any honest observation will likely lead to the uncovering of missteps and failures. Some of those may be your own decisions from weeks or months ago. Embrace the learning versus the negative feelings of having a miss on the books. Acknowledging that and course correcting will not only improve results, but will send a powerful message to your team, your peers, and your boss that you’re not above making a mistake. You’re making adjustments to move towards more positive outcomes. Recognize it. Own it. Address it. Learn from it.

Proactive mindset

Reaction is normal. Proaction is leadership action. That may be a little corny, but there is a lot of truth to it. The key here is mindset. We must first be open to the idea that the reality we see is not the actual reality that others experience. When we work within an environment day after day, we can become numb to many of the symptoms of problems that are brewing. That is why using data, observations, and learnings are so critical. But, none of those will matter if you do not have a mindset of using that information to get ahead of problems instead of justifying the causes you are seeing.

"Don't wait for the right opportunity. Create it." — George Bernard Shaw

Ask for help

Retail leadership can feel heavy and lonely a lot. If everyone else in your district is doing well in an area, and you have fallen behind, it can feel like you’re the only one that has ever had this problem. In my experience (and even in my own actions), what we think (everyone has this figured out, they won’t want to help me) is far different from what will really happen. Pause for a moment and ask yourself this, “if one of my peers came to me asking for help, would I help them or share my advice?” I am willing to bet that you say ‘of course’ to that statement. I am also willing to bet that 99.9% of your peers would say the same thing and will do just that if you ask for help. Leveraging the knowledge of others is likely one of the most overlooked power tools in all retail. People are just afraid to ask for help or look to their peers for advice. Buck that trend, pick up the phone and talk about what struggles you are facing and if they have any ideas on how you can approach it differently. I think you may be surprised how willing others are to help.

Remember, facing reality head on requires courage, honesty, and a willingness to take necessary actions. These suggested actions above can help you face those realities in your business. Embrace them and make them your own. All of them require setting your ego aside and being open to the potential truths that exist for your situation. The best part, you can overcome any of the challenges you face. Ask questions, observe behaviors and outcomes, review the data and trust it. Talk to friends, peers, mentors to get new ideas, and if something fails, learn from it and try again. You can succeed, if you are always open with the realities you face.

Are you ready to embrace a proactive mindset and unlock the power of data-driven decision-making in your retail business? What changes will you make?

Join other retail leaders in continuing their development journey with Effective Retail Leader.com. SUBSCRIBE today to receive leadership tips directly to your inbox and monthly newsletters that provide many tools to help further develop your leadership skills. JOIN NOW!

Photo by Alan Tang on Unsplash